The second chair position is paradoxical for two reasons. First, a second chair involves the tension of submitting as a subordinate to the first chair while at the same time leading with a high level of influence. Second chairs maintain a dependence on the first chair while at the same time managing the significant amounts of freedom found near the top of the chain of command. Additionally, the second paradox involves being in an ever-changing role that is difficult to define while at the same time trying to add structure to the vision of the first chair. Second chairs often find themselves in the unenviable position of being the Jell-O others are trying to nail to the wall.
Whether it’s a paid or unpaid position, formal or informal, most churches have a strong leader serving under the lead (or sole) pastor. In smaller churches, this person can be a prominent layperson. In larger churches, the position is often an executive pastor. Numerous titles describe this position, including associate and administrator. Other church leadership positions can also be second chairs, such as a worship pastor. In this article, I will refer to the position simply as the second chair.
This post is about second chairs but directed to first chairs. How can lead pastors serve those whose main item on the job description is to serve them?
Serve first, lead second, and teach servant leadership. All church leaders should take on the posture of serving first and leading second, but a personal example is not enough. First chairs cannot assume second chairs (and other staff members) will follow the example of servant leadership if it is simply lived out and never taught. First chairs must do more than encourage others to serve. They must teach others how to be servant leaders. First chairs should direct second chairs and staff to be aware of more than just what they should do, but also who they are in Christ. Servant leadership is more than a list of positive and negative traits. Servant leadership is more than a list of helpful or unhelpful actions. Being a servant leader like Jesus is an identity. This identity has a biblical foundation, and it must be taught.
Create a partnership, not a dictatorship. Living servant leadership and teaching servant leadership are essential to creating a culture of servant leadership. But this culture is unsustainable (as is just about everything else in the church) without a partnership. Treating second chairs and staff as partners rather than employees will help sustain a transformational servant leadership environment. A first chair’s goal is to create a partnership and not give directives like an overbearing boss. This partnership of servant leadership can be fostered with transparency and clarity.
Balance authority and responsibility. The temptation for a first chair is to seize power and control from the second chair. In the hierarchy of command, it is easier for a first chair to pull authority from a second chair than for a second chair to take it from a first chair. One of the ministry tensions of the second chair is leading and adding value to the church without the positional authority of the lead pastor. A subordinate leader can only influence upward if the senior leader gives him or her the corresponding authority to do so.
One of the first chair’s primary responsibilities is serving the second chair. Nothing invalidates leadership like abandoning a servant’s heart. A first chair’s relationship with a second chair is one of a partnership, not a dictatorship. In this partnership, the first chair should grant a second chair a high level of authority to accomplish the tasks of his or her responsibility.
At Church Answers Central, we cover a variety of topics and answer these kinds of questions every day. Church Answers Central is the world’s largest online community for practical ministry support. Get 24/7 answers to your church questions. Join a vibrant community of nearly 2,000 church leaders in a safe environment. Connect with top church health experts like Thom Rainer, Chuck Lawless, Sam Rainer, and others like you. Become a member today!
Posted on April 26, 2023
As President of Church Answers, Sam Rainer wears many hats. From podcast co-host to full-time Pastor at West Bradenton Baptist Church, Sam’s heart for ministry and revitalization are evident in all he does.
More from Sam